Note to those who receive new posts via e-mail: You must
click on the title of the new post, highlighted above in blue, in order to
access images and sound.
On March 12, 2016,
the Metropolitan Opera will broadcast via radio its matinee of Gaetano
Donizetti’s comic opera, Don Pasquale.
The eponymous role generally falls to a specialist in the comic characters of
Mozart (Leporello in Don Giovanni, for example), or Rossini (Don Bartolo
in Il Barbiere di Siviglia), or, of course, Donizetti
himself (Dulcamara in L’Elisir d’amore). The success of the basso
buffo hangs on the ability to regale the audience, to incite its laughter, more
than it does on the quality of the voice. Above all, the bass must have
the nimble diction that delivers rapid-fire patter, source of much of the fun.
Often drawn from the company’s second rank, the basso buffo is nevertheless
expected to carry significant musical and theatrical responsibility, yet he is
rarely an opera’s focal point. Don
Pasquale departs from this norm. In this ensemble work for a quartet of
singers, the basso buffo is the central figure.
If we are to
believe the reviewers, Salvatore Baccaloni was the first Met Pasquale, in the
forty years since the opera’s company premiere, to grab and hold the
spotlight. In the 1940 revival, and only then, did the basso buffo take
full charge by upstaging his colleagues. The matinee broadcast, which we
had access to in a recording, the one cheered by critics present in the opera
house, does justice to Baccaloni’s outsized personality, reflected in his rich,
shuddery voice; the delighted audience is frequently heard in appreciative
response to his antics. Even the cool and acerbic Virgil Thomson agreed
that the afternoon belonged to the bass, whom he compared to actors of genius
Mary Garden, Fyodor Chaliapin, W. C. Fields, and Raimu! Baccaloni, who reigned
as the Met’s principal basso buffo until the debut of Fernando Corena in 1954,
continued to sing with the company until 1965.
Here is Baccaloni
in a 1932 Italian recording of the Act III duet between Don Pasquale and Doctor
Malatesta (the baritone is Emilio Ghirardini). Pasquale, a rich, stingy old
bachelor, has been tricked into a mock marriage by his friend, Malatesta.
Pasquale believes he has found proof that his much, much younger, spiteful, and
spendthrift “wife,” Norina, is cheating on him, and with Malatesta, is elated
at the prospect of catching her “in flagrante.” The second part of the duet
requires the rapid-fire delivery to which we made allusion above.
In a 1979 video of
this same duet, with subtitles in English, the great Welsh buffo Geraint Evans
offers a Pasquale less broad than Baccaloni’s, but just as funny. He and
Russell Smyth, the Malatesta, both anglophones, are adept at articulating the
patter of the conclusion.
The rendez-vous of
Norina and her young lover, Ernesto, is a passage of sustained lyricism that we
count among the most ravishing in all opera. First, Ernesto, Pasquale’s nephew
who wants to marry Norina, sings a lilting serenade. Cesare Valletti, who took
the role in the Met’s 1955 revival, was the company’s principal tenore di
grazia through the 1950s. He tempers the over-the-top protestations of love
declaimed for Pasquale’s benefit with his customary sincerity, sweet timbre,
and command of subtle dynamics.
Following the
serenade, without pause, Ernesto and Norina, their voices echoing and
entwining, sing a love duet designed to enrage the presumably cuckolded
Pasquale. “Tornami a dir” is a test for the singers as they match phrasing,
stress, and tonal beauty at pianissimo level. In this 1930s recording, Tito
Schipa and Toti Dal Monte ply their bel canto techniques to achieve a
remarkable unison.
Like all operas
designated “buffa,” Don Pasquale ends happily. The foolish faux husband,
having seen the error of his ways, gives his blessing to the young couple.