It has been some months since Operapost published its last entry. We take up our blog again, glad to be joining the individuals and organizations that are bringing more and more music into our isolation. Their number and reach tell us how very crucial music is at this moment and how critical the diffusion of music of all genres has become.
Over the years, our posts have centered largely on the history
of New York’s dominant opera company, the Metropolitan. The Covid-19
pandemic that has attacked New York so cruelly, draws us once again
to the Met’s past, particularly as we contemplate its future. In
this installment, we look to three critical periods of the company’s history:
that of the 1918 Spanish flu, of the Great Depression, and of the 1969
stand-off between management and labor that shut the theater for months. How
the company fared during and after these crises may help us to anticipate how
the Met will survive the current humanitarian and economic catastrophe.
Although New York was hit
less hard than nearby Boston and Philadelphia during the three waves of the
Spanish flu it endured between September 1918 and February 1919, the city
suffered a terrible blow. Thirty thousand New Yorkers of a
total population of 5,600,000 died. Theaters and other entertainments,
including the Metropolitan Opera, remained open for the entire 1918-1919
season--albeit under stricter regulation and inspection by the Department of
Health. And despite its full performance
schedule, in the ten years that separate 1911 from 1921, the 1918-1919 season
saw the deepest dip in gross box-office receipts.
More telling than the comparison between the Spanish flu and
Covid-19 on the operations of the company is the comparison of the effects of
the strike of 1969 with the current closure. (See our three posts on
labor-management conflict at the Met, Ars et Labor: 1. The Met, 1906-1966, Ars et Labor: 2. The Met, 1969, Ars et Labor: 3. The Met, 1980). Under General Manager Rudolf Bing,
the Met shut its doors for three months, from September to December. When the
company finally opened the delayed season, the average percentage of filled
seats fell from 96% to 89%. A significant number of patrons failed to renew
their subscriptions. Eleven years later, in 1980, when yet another contract
dispute threatened the season, subscriptions still lagged behind the 1969 tally
by 16%. We should note that as recently as the 2016-17 season the capacity at
the Met was 67% and the strength of its financial profile is
not nearly what it was in the late 1960s.
The current predictions of depression-level unemployment in the
coming months suggest that even a fleeting glance at the effects of the Great Depression on the
Met may be instructive. The company stayed afloat, unlike the Chicago Civic
Opera forced to go under by its balance sheet. The fragile equilibrium that
obtained through 1929–30 was undone by the more than 10% decline in
subscriptions in 1930–31 and another 10% the next year. Principal
singers, with very few exceptions, agreed to reductions in contracts and
fees. Ticket prices were lowered; the lost revenue was offset by a major
reorganization. As 1932–33 began to take shape, and more than one-tenth
of the city’s population was on public or private assistance, the season was shortened
from twenty-four to sixteen weeks, and subscription costs were halved and
individual ticket prices reduced in order to generate more robust sales. But the drastically reduced prices did little to spur subscriptions. The
company took to the radio in a “Save the Met” campaign. Within two months
the $300,000 goal was achieved. An astonishing one-third of the total was
contributed by radio listeners. (We will devote our next post to the story of
the Saturday afternoon broadcasts.)
The Met was, in no small part, “saved” also by the box-office draw
of a late-1930s contingent of superlative Wagnerians. (See our three posts, Wagner's Last Golden Age at the Met: I, The Dramatic Soprano, Wagner's Last Golden Age at the Met: II, The Heroic Tenor, Wagner's Last Golden Age at the Met: III, Other Voices) on this remarkable moment of
Met performance history.) The stars of this cohort were the Norwegian dramatic
soprano Kirsten Flagstad and the Danish heldentenor Lauritz Melchior. The
Flagstad-Melchior team guaranteed a full house in the seven seasons they sang
together in New York—a stunning average of nearly thirty performances per
season. We hear them at their peak in this 1939 studio recording of the duet that
marks the triumphant finale of the prologue to Götterdämmerung. As the
lovers declare their transcendent passion, Brünnhilde urges Siegfried on to new
heights of heroism. Like the audiences of the Great Depression, we too are lifted
out of our gloom by the boundless exuberance of these voices.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Please enter your comment here: